The 5 Softest Mattresses From Organic Brands (2023)

The Good Trade editors endorse products we’ve personally researched, tested, and genuinely love. Learn more about our methodology and business model here.

Side sleepers, rejoice, for it’s finally your time to shine. 🪩💤

While stomach and back sleepers normally opt for firmer mattresses, side sleepers (this editor included) can benefit from softer mattresses. The same goes for those with joint pain in the shoulder, hips, or back, or lightweight individuals — mattresses that contour to your shape and provide relief are invaluable for good sleep. With that in mind, you’ll want a soft mattress that offers spinal alignment, cushioned top layers to alleviate pressure points, and any sort of memory foam, innerspring, or hybrid combo. 

But bear in mind, many mattresses out there are made with polyurethane (derived from oil), chemical fire retardants, and hazardous VOCs (volatile organic compounds). Considering we spend a third of our lives in bed, the risk of exposure and/or inhalation of these compounds runs high. That’s why we’re focused on the best organic mattress — the materials are nontoxic, they’re more sustainable, and they often last longer than synthetics. 

We’ve found five of the softest mattresses on the market from organic and sustainable brands. Our editors have personally tested these products, spoken to the brands, and/or scoured online reviews to select the absolute best, and this guide is updated regularly with new favorites. Plus, all of these brands also offer generous warranties, financing plans, and customer service support to ensure you’re happy with your new super soft purchase.

Our criteria:

  • SOFTNESS | Most bedding companies use a scale of 1 to 10, 1 being the softest. We’d consider anything under a 4.5 to be on the softer side, with most of the options below ranging from 2–3.
  • ORGANIC | Each of these brands uses organic, sustainable, and nontoxic materials including organic cotton, organic wool, plant-based BioFoam, and natural latex. Any additional organic certifications are mentioned alongside the brand below.

If a new mattress is out of the budget — or your current mattress still has a lot of life left — but you’re hoping for a softer experience, consider our list of the best organic mattress toppers.


1. Saatva

Best For | Various sizes and heights
Softness Rating | 3/10
Features & Certifications | Hybrid innerspring, CertiPUR-US certified, made in the USA, free white glove delivery, 365-night trial, lifetime warranty, 24/7 customer support, financing available
Nontoxic Materials | Organic cotton, nontoxic Guardin antimicrobial treatment, eco-friendly foam, natural pulp barrier
Sizes Available | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, Cal King, Split Cal King
Price | Queen mattresses starting at $1,695

Saatva Classic Plush Soft is great for those who really want to customize their bed. There are eight different sizes, two heights, and three comfort levels to choose from — and the plush soft is ideal for side sleepers who want extra relief. And while it is very cushioned, you won’t feel as though you’re sinking into the mattress since it’s supported by hundreds of steel coils and designed to enjoy healthy spinal alignment. (It’s also finished with an organic cotton cover for added breathability and comfort!)

Made to order in the US, Saatva offers free white glove delivery and set up (including taking your old mattress away for free!) and a one-year home trial. The team also touts a lifetime warranty on its mattresses and has always-on customer service. The dedication is real and you can rest easy (pun intended) knowing you have the flexibility you need.


2. Avocado

Best For | Luxury ultra-plush mattress
Softness Rating | 3/10
Features & Certifications | Certified B Corp, MADE SAFE, Greenguard, GOTS, & FSC certified, made in the USA, 3” box top, 24-year limited warranty, 1-year trial, in-home delivery required, financing available 
Nontoxic Materials | Organic cotton & wool, natural Alpaca fiber, organic natural Dunlop latex
Sizes Available | Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Price | Queen mattresses starting at $5,799

Avocado’s Organic Mattress in Ultra Plush may actually redefine luxury. With a whopping 17 (!) premium layers and thousands of individually encased coils, this mattress is about as top-of-the-line as you can get. Here’s how it breaks down: The Ultra Plush model comes in at 19” high, including multiple layers of organic latex, cotton, wool, and alpaca fibers, plus a 3” box top comfort layer. That translates to an impressive seven ergonomic zones for support — so side sleepers seeking relief in their hips and shoulders will easily find it. Plus, it’s loved by our editors — for more deets, check out our in-depth review.

With the most eco-friendly certifications we’ve ever seen on one mattress, Avocado’s commitment to minimizing its footprint and maximizing sustainability is unparalleled. Plus, one percent of all revenue is donated to 1% for the Planet and the beds are climate-neutral. In-home delivery is required starting at $249, but thanks to the impressive warranty, customer service, and 0% financing, we think this one is worth the investment if you’re looking for luxury.


3. Bear

Best For | Cooling mattress
Softness Rating | 5/10
Features & Certifications | Hybrid innerspring & memory foam, cooling technology, CertiPUR-US & Greenguard certified, made in the USA, 120-night trial, lifetime warranty, free shipping & returns, financing available
Nontoxic Materials | Copper-infused memory foam, Celiant fibers
Sizes Available | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King
Price | Queen mattresses starting at $2,305

Side sleepers who run hot will want to pick up the Bear Elite Hybrid Mattress in Soft. This hybrid mattress leverages copper-infused memory foam, zoned coil system, and thermoregulating fibers to keep you calm and cool all night long — while simultaneously offering relief to your joints. It’s so cool to the touch, you can say goodbye forever to tossing, turning, and waking up sweaty.

Bear has been named a top mattress by numerous publications — and we certainly agree. This award-winning bed is made in Arizona and ships to you for absolutely free. (Returns are free, too — but we sense you may not need that!) Bear also provides a lifetime warranty and 120-night trial to ensure you enjoy this mattress for the long-term. Breathable, sustainable, and durable. Ahh. (That’s a sigh of relief.)


4. Happsy

Best For | Plush and topper combo
Softness Rating | 2/10
Features & Certifications | MADE SAFE, Greenguard, & GOTS certified, hybrid innerspring & latex foam, made in the USA, 120-night trial, free shipping & returns, 20-year warranty
Nontoxic Materials | Organic cotton, wool, & latex
Sizes Available | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King
Price | Queen mattresses starting at $1,399; queen toppers starting at $399

For the softest mattress on the list, check out Happsy’s Organic Mattress and Topper combo: The 10” mattress is made up of organic latex and pocketed springs, and the 2” topper comprises organic cotton and latex. Combine them together, and you’ll feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud. ☁️

Free of fire retardants, adhesives, or polyurethane, Happsy prioritizes natural materials as much as possible — even nixing the glue you’ll find within most encased coils. Instead, these mattresses are certified sustainable and fully made in the USA. Your purchase includes free shipping, free returns, a 120-night trial, monthly financing options, and a 20-year warranty, and a percentage of all orders goes to 1% for the Planet. With a mattress like that, you’ll feel like you’re living the dream.


5. Brentwood

Best For | Balancing affordability with quality
Softness Rating | 4.5/10
Features & Certifications | CertiPUR-US, GOTS, Greenguard, & Fair Trade certified, climate-neutral, hybrid innerspring & memory foam, made in the USA, free shipping & returns, 1-year trial, 25-year warranty
Nontoxic Materials | Organic wool & cotton, plant-based BioFoam, Tencel
Sizes Available | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King
Price | Queen mattresses starting at $1,839

Brentwood’s Oceano is their best-selling luxury mattress, and we can see why. For under $2,000 for a queen, the company’s beds tout nine layers, including thousands of supportive coils, cooling gel-infused memory foam, and luxurious organic materials like wool and poly-silk. What you won’t find here? Any chemical or fiber flame retardants, high VOC materials, or carbon footprint.

Brentwood handcrafts all mattresses in their organic factory just outside Los Angeles, and each mattress is certified fair trade and sustainable. Standard shipping and returns are free, though you can add optional in-home delivery. You can try your mattress for up to a full year if you need. If you’re not sure if the Oceano is for you, you can also book a Zoom demo to see it in action and hear from the customer support team. It’s risk-free from start to finish.